On reigning it in

It’s so hard.

Every day, I see this little sponge covered in blonde hair and blue eyes and applesauce, and I have to stop myself from going with what my guts speak. To silence them, cognisant that if I just pushed a little harder, or quizzed a little more, or held my hand over hers, then maybe she’d be further ahead.

I tell myself to shut up for the simple reason that I would never tell her that she should or will be a doctor, just because she cares so deeply about people’s welfare, hurts and heartaches: because it’s not up to me to push her as far as I can in any arena. Because I don’t want to predetermine her outcome.

I love that she’s in love with letters and words. Could I ensure that she was reading before preschool ended by focusing wholly on it? Maybe. She’s part-way there, already. But I have to pause, every time it occurs to me to intentionally teach her a new word. I have to let her come to me.

All of this constant abeyance doesn’t diminish my want to get her ahead. Or to get her to where the other kids in her preschool class might be.

I walk past those damn display boards outside of the classroom, with all of their crayoned normality, and I see all of the faces those four year olds are drawing. I hear her best friend count up to 49 and then ask what comes next.

I have watched her go from no numbers to plateauing at 14, and knowing 16 and 18 and 19 follow, but not which is first, or what’s between them, or that there is anything between at all. I refuse to pick up the art and ask her what it is, because I see how that might make art have to be about making a picture of something, instead of just creating. So she scribbles and I see how she takes up no more than 1/10th of each page, and often chooses to work in black. Heaven forbid a child psychologist ever see this work.

I refuse to make her practice counting, but I count out loud a lot, too, because she asks me to. I don’t tell her what numbers are without asking her what she might think, just in case she’s tricking me into thinking she doesn’t know them – this frustrates her but it doesn’t insult her.

I still have to cease comparing, because even if it wasn’t like putting dragonfruit up against every other form of produce, she’s three and I’m slotting her development with kids who will be turning five this year. With children who have had the benefit of a parent at home, 100% devoted to them and their learning potential. Kids who’ve been in art, gymnastics, ballet, swim, music and sign language classes. With kids who live with two parents, and have grandparents they see regularly, who don’t have dads who look at the clock on a bad day while counting down to when their next drink could be, and all of the other forms of nuclear our family detonates. Children who didn’t spend the first two years of their lives mainly in the throws of some sort of tantrum or sickness, or with a mother who was doing the same.

If it isn’t comparing, it’s about seeing genius in some facets of her. And that has to end, too.

If I really went for it, sure, I might make her be able to read before her 4th birthday. But what would it cost her? All of the lessons, the quizzes, the performing, and the expectation… would it help her to remain a lover of books, or would she grow to see them as work and unsatisfying, very quickly?

So, another day goes by where I reserve the jerk to list easy words on our white board, thinking I can teach them to her. I don’t sit down with paper and crayons, saying, “Here’s where the eyes go… and now, a nose…” I won’t pull out flash cards and try to fool her into thinking that rote memorization of digits is a game, simply because I worry that she won’t be the smartest motherfucker around.

And it’s so hard. Because now, now that schooling has been decided, it feels like a project. And if there’s anything I like better than the imagery of Jason Mraz naked, it’s a new project.

Related Posts with Thumbnails
  • Momisodes

    "Or to get her to where the other kids in her preschool class might be."..."If it isn’t comparing, it’s about seeing genius in some facets of
    her. And that has to end, too..."

    I cannot tell you how much I can relate to this post right now.

    It is so hard to just sit back sometimes. Especially now, when they're so willing and open.

  • Right?! It's like, Babisodes is holding out a pencil, asking you to teach her to write a book and you're all, "um, how about we learn your name?" because a book is just HUGE and un-three.

  • I think, above and beyond not pushing her too hard too soon, you may be doing her more of a favour than you realize: if you're not comparing her to others, perhaps she won't compare herself either. Lord knows I need a lesson (or twelve) in just accepting and going with the flow. Good on ya, lady. <3

  • Amen, sister. We ALL, vagina-owners, need to work on not comparing ourselves.

  • my Kid also likes to work in black. so what? let him. as for all the other crayons - he thinks they're pretty tasty ;)

  • I knew a girl like that - who liked the taste of crayons. Mind you, she was 17, and dropped a lot of acid. :P

    I miss seeing your face.

  • This all sounds like a very natural way to learn.

  • Take your time. Let her be three. All those people pushing their kids to read a gagillion levels above their kids' ages are not doing them any favors. Keep up, yes. Encourage to practice the things she loves and explore the things that are new. But what's a 12 year-old gonna do with a physics degree if she can't ride a bike or make a friend?

  • So THAT'S why I never rode bikes. My dad had me doing computer programming in grade one, because I asked once how to make something do something.

  • Laura

    I had some of those same feelings about whether I should push my son harder when he was smaller. He knew some letters and when he started pre-k (age 4) last year, but not too much. Now, midway through kindergarten (age 5) he reads on his own. I am amazed at the learning that he has experience in his first year in school. So - it will come - no need to push.

    Also, my understanding is that research shows that reading early doesn't necessarily predict success in later years. I don't want to try to say too much because I haven't actually read the research, but, again, my understanding is that studies have shown that there is a "leveling out" effect b/w kids who read early and ones that don't. By the time they hit 2nd or 3rd grade or so, there is no significant difference in their reading levels.

    Just something to think about....

  • I've read about that as well - except what I'd heard was that it typically evens out (as far as "early" or "late" readers) by 11. The problem I'm having, really, isn't pushing her *to* read - it's sitting back and waiting for her to come to me with interest. It's like, I know that she wants more, that she's interested, and I want to encourage it, but I think it would be disrespectful, of a sort, to jump into it without her request.

    I don't know. Unschooling's confusing!

  • kristen

    If you are planning to be her teacher, you are going to have to get comfortable with the role. And if you aren't comfortable with it, have someone else do it.

    My boy is turning 5 in just a couple months and the comparison between him a year ago and now is amazing. He is writing, reading a bit, drawing pictures of things I can distinguish. Junior Kindergarten has made a big difference. Not just in his ability, but in his confidence in his ability. He is also encouraged and challenged by the kids around him.

    Try not to compare her to others. Just acknowledge her own progress.

  • But Kristen, I'm *not* planning to be her teacher - that's the whole point. I think, even as a homeschooling mom, that my role should be one of facilitator, but not instructor.

  • keep hangin' in there lady. also, i love the new digs!!

  • Thank you!

  • hockeymandad

    With our girls, we simply encouraged curiosity and when interest was shown we engage them. If you make it fun and full of praise for simple wins, they won't see it as work. My oldest craves knowledge and my youngest craves to be like her big sister. There's something special when your daughter asks if she can read a book to you and then does it.

    Comparing can only make you feel worse about yourself. I can easily see that path. All I do is ask for interest in something and encourage without pressure. They will handle the rest.

  • Sounds like y'all got some ECE in the house. And a firm grasp of how I think it should be done.

  • This weblog is being featured on Five Star Friday - http://www.fivestarfriday.com/...

  • Ian

    Keep holding your horses love.

  • Indeed. Will do.

blog comments powered by Disqus