On the hard questions

“Mama, do you remember when I had a baby brother or sister?”

For some reason, her memory goes back far enough to remember when I was pregnant last year, 14 months ago. “Yes, I remember when we thought you would have one. But you don’t have one now, do you?”

“No. It died.” She says this so matter-of-factly that it sucks air from my cells. “Mama, do you miss the baby from your tummy?”

“Sometimes, baby, yes, I do.”

“And that makes your heart hurt?”

“Yes, sometimes it does.”

And then she kisses me and asks if it made my heart feel better.

***

“Mama, what’s the name of your mom? Can I go to meet her soon?”

“One day, baby,” I say, not committing to a date or circumstances. Because there’s no reason not to introduce her to my mother and vice versa, yet something’s holding me back. It feels forced, the thought of it, so I know I’m not ready, yet.

***

“Mama, what’s your dad’s name?”

“Jim, love.”

“And he died, so he’s not alive any more. Right, Mama?”

“That’s right, baby.”

“So we can’t go see him. And he won’t come to our home?”

“No, baby. He won’t.”

“Was your daddy nice, like K’s daddy?”

“No, baby, he wasn’t.”

“Did he make you sad?”

“Yes, baby, he did.”

“That’s not a nice thing to do, when your daddy made you sad.”

“No, baby. It wasn’t.”

***

“Mama, do you love daddy?”

“Yes, baby.”

“Why?”

“Because I do. Because he gave me you and he’s been my best friend for a long time.”

“And daddy loves you because he shared with you his chicken. Right, Mama?”

“Sure, love. That sounds about right.”

“And he shares his drinks with you.”

“Yes, he does sometimes.”

“He doesn’t share them with me. They’re for grown ups cuz they got alcohol.”

“Exactly. You won’t drink grown-up drinks for a long time.”

“I just drink soy milk, or juice, or smoothies, or hot chocolate. Or water.”

She turns her hand over and over, as if dealing out the drink options. She doesn’t know that this conversation is the closest to heart breaking that we’ll have to deal with for a long time.

***

“Mama, are you mad with me?”

“No, baby, I’m not mad. Why do you think so?”

“Um, cuz your eyes look sad, but your mouth is mad.”

I’m humbled, thinking I was doing a much better job at keeping my stressful weight off of her shoulders. She’s a mind-reader, apparently.

***

“Mama, can I have a new brother or sister?”

“Maybe one day, baby. Do you want a brother, or do you want a sister?”

“I want a new baby so I can help with you rocking it and singing quiet so it sleeps.”

“Don’t you want the baby to play with?”

“Babies are loud. When they sleep, they’re not too loud for my ears.”

“So why do you want a baby, Isobel?”

“So I can love my own baby and it will love me back.”

I wonder if she’ll ever know that that’s the exact reason why she’s here now; I hope she doesn’t have her own children for that same selfish reason.

***

I’m always honest, but as you can see, I don’t hand her a dialogue of history. I answer her questions in a three-year-old-friendly way (at least I think so), but I don’t hide things or lie, either. It’s interesting: the facts she retains, the blanks she fills in for herself, the awareness she’s starting to show.

It’s like her mind is just opening right up, wondering why our life is the way it is. Asking what markers were on our map to today.

And then, just like that, with barely a blink, she snaps out of seriousness and becomes a silly little girl. Just as she probably should be.

Related Posts with Thumbnails
  • She is a treasure, isn't she! So smart, intuitive and sensitive!
  • Thanks for the sharing. At least I know how I'm going to talk to my first baby in the coming year.
  • I'm a champion for just talking to your kids like your would an adult. Not using baby-talk, or too much simplicity. And seriously, it's amazed me how much my daughter's understood over the years, before she was even talking.
  • Al_Pal
    Awww, the video is so darling. Those giggles and smiles. :D

    the conversations. Ach. *HUGS*
  • ccoplick
    Dude. She up talks.

    omg. I loooooove that giggle. I love making her MAKE that giggle. omg. I've listened to this 3x now.

    I freakin' ADORE her. I don't want my own, I want to hang with YOURS. Dude. You pump em out, I';; hang with them between the ages of 2 and 6. mmmmk? ;)
  • I dunno about pumping them out. I mean, I think I have enough stretch marks to last me a life-time already. AND I'd probably need a willing babydaddy.
  • What a fabulous laugh! I'm actually tearing up, she is so adorable. She will benefit from what you went through, she knows she is cherished and precious.
  • Oh, we've already instilled in her that she's our miracle baby. She doesn't quite get, 100%, what that means, but she knows that I wasn't able to have a baby, and then, like magic, I had her and it made me super happy.
  • Mwa
    Beautiful beautiful beautiful.
  • That was 3 minutes and 33 seconds of the most beautiful sound on this earth. The sigh at the end? PERFECTION.

    She's going to be ok Terra. She's going to be more than OK.
  • Oh, I think she's gonna be awesome. Or rather, money.
  • this is probably the era of parenting that intimidates me most... when they really become aware of the things around them and start asking questions.
  • I'm actually finding it the most interesting, dood. Even though some days, I think that if I hear "why?" one more time, I might explode, it's pretty awesome to realize that she really DOES care about the whys of like, everything.
  • Those conversations are the hardest, and also the best. My son has an insanely good memory, and an uncanny understanding of what I'm feeling at any given time.
  • Do you guys have what seems like a psychic connection some times? I mean, some moments, I'll be sitting there, thinking of a conversation with someone and she'll ask, completely out of the blue when we'll be seeing them again. Trips me the fuck out.
  • Ahhhh, so beautiful. These conversations are so wonderful. I have them very frequently with my girls. You are answering perfectly. They don't need the entire picture or story, they won't understand everything. However they do put things together in an amazing way and therefore you must be honest with them or else they'll figure it out eventually.

    My oldest loves these moments, but not as much as I do I think. These little moments are so important yet so amazing as a parent to watch and see your child hunger for knowledge and understanding. The business with making "your heart" feel better with kisses is incredible. I dunno where they get that from but it's a concept I hope stays with them forever.

    Thanks for sharing such a personal moment.
  • I blame Ni Hao Ki Lan.
  • Kel
    So intuitive. Children have a way of knowing - even if they don't really ever know. I am here because 'she wanted someone to love her' and for as much as I'm happy to be here...there are days I wish I didn't know that.
    Keep being honest with her....
    ~K
  • It's a tough call, whether to be completely honest about that facet or not. So far, I've left it at "because we decided that we wanted a baby just like you." Which is true, even though we didn't know what it meant when we found out we were pregnant and cursed a lot.
  • Oh but that giggle. That giggle lightens everything up. My daughters were grinning from ear to ear watching her.
blog comments powered by Disqus