On Being Alternative

I do a lot of things differently. I plan to do a lot of things differently. Differently than most I know, that is.

In December, JDawg argued the merits of me refusing to tell Isobel about Santa. He considered it stealing from her childhood and something I’d do to be trendy.

I don’t lie to Isobel. I don’t make up white lies to get her to stop asking questions, or tell her about bunnies bringing Easter eggs, or that her father is a perfect daddy or I am a perfect mommy. I won’t. Refuse, honestly. I am authentic with her, to a fault. I tell her when I’m getting frustrated or upset. I don’t mince words about how I feel or the world around us, if I think she’s overreacting or I don’t understand her toddler ease. I tell her she’s being rude when she doesn’t say hello back to a homeless person. This is why Santa was not whored out.

When I told friends in my neighbourhood that I planned to home school Isobel, they looked at me in surprise, asking questions about socialization and how I planned to not lose my fool mind without her being away from me for most of the day.

When I was in school, I was bored. I was too smart, too shy and too fat – as a little kid – to get away with being a wallflower. So I did a 180. By 8th grade, I was a constant talk-out-louder, high as a fucking kite and challenging myself to get the lowest grade possible in classes I’d otherwise ace. Becoming a ‘dumb slut’? Worked. I was no longer picked on, singled out (much) or thrust into the spotlight when I didn’t choose to tapdance my way in from stage left. I was still bored. So I dropped out. Again and again.

JDawg? Also a dropper outer. Also bored. Also the life of the party – literally – and into chemical consumption and problems with authority. But we both love to learn. Which is why enrolling Isobel in a self-directed learning program, outside of the public school system is important to me. Because I want her to enjoy her education, not loathe it, but still hunger for real knowledge.

Someone asked, an online friend, how we lived, about our lifestyle and I said that we shared a bed in a 400 square foot apartment. Then they asked why I didn’t live somewhere bigger, with my own bed, in a different neighbourhood.

We live where we do because it’s the cheapest in the neighbourhood and if I have to be in Vancouver, which I pretty much do, because of JDawg, then it’s here. There is nowhere else I’ve known in my city where streets are littered with fashionistas, starving students, homeless, married gay couples loving each other openly, mommies and daddies wearing Ergo carriers, flocks of Spanish nannies and their charges and dogs. And they’re all interacting with each other in a polite manner. Nearly all.

This is the most diverse area I’ve seen, with every income level represented, every marital status, every ideal and disillusion. And I want her raised to think that’s what the world does look like, not should look like. It means we have a tiny place. Big diff. Space doesn’t equal grace, I figure.

Why do you spend so much money on groceries? Why doesn’t she eat candy?

Since she was born, I’ve had it ingrained in my head – raise her to eat right. Don’t make her one of those kids that people sneer about. She’s become, over the past year and especially once the potty training bribes were brought out, a chocolate lover. With the exclusion of dairy, all chocolate’s gone out the window and now, rarely, she gets some carob. Now, for allergy testing’s sake, we’re excluding soy and wheat (something I intended to do, myself, about two months ago) from our diets as well. It means she, and in turn I, mostly eat fruits, vegetables and meat, with some alternative protein sources and carb sources thrown in as an afterthought.

It costs more. She’s got more energy and so do I, technically. It’s a trade off, since I didn’t especially think she needed more energy. And as a general rule, we don’t do filler foods and treats are something crazy wacky like a piece of 100% fruit leather. We go big – choosing for her to get something really different instead of something really sugary and synthetic. It works, so why stop?

You mean, you don’t vaccinate, at all?

I vaccinated her for her first year. While she was freshly immunologically challenged. While she was getting a new cold or flu every three weeks, each lasting at least 10 days, resulting in an ear infection, whose antibiotic side effects would bring about diarrhea so badly that she’d get a diaper rash that’d burst open, cracking and bleeding while a yeast infection would take over at the same time. Every three weeks. Eleven times.

Vaccinations didn’t help shit. And I’m sorry, call me naive, but I believe in the principle that if I’m not supposed to get something – because my body should, at its optimal health, be able to fight disease and sickness and repair itself, too – I won’t.

And I also believe in survival of the fittest. And evolution and mutation and super-viruses and ultimately not in the genetic manipulation of human beings. Sorry. I know that makes me a monster of a mother, but it’s true.

She dresses herself? She eats when she wants to? She decides on everything?

I allow Isobel a choice in every. single. thing. But not too much for her age. For instance, I will not tell her to pick what she’s wearing that day and expect her to. I will ask her if she wants a dress or pants. Then stripes, hearts, or flowers? This one, this one, or this one? Tights or leggings (because it’s always a dress, now)? Then, which of three pairs of shoes.

Everything works like that, for as long as I can see her being engaged in the process. If she shows a sign of being bored, uninterested or burnt out, I take over. And I always have the final say. But she always gets a vote, if she’s capable of taking it.

You know why? Because I figure that those boundary pushing interludes that two and three year olds are great for? Might be worn down a little if she feels like she has some control. Because I want to nourish decision-making skills in her, and especially independent thinking ability, from a very young age. Because she can.

She has how many books and like, no toys?

I’ve never really bought her toys. That’s what grandparents and friends and other family are for. What I have always done is made sure she’s gotten at least one new book a month. Now, with a discount bookstore moving literally a block and a half away, you could say we’ve both vastly expanded our book collections. This means, I think, she’s always going to be surrounded by books. Hopefully her love of being read to and ‘reading to herself’ (now, in the form of story-telling via pictures) and the normalcy of a book coming before a toy might mean something later on. Maybe she’ll be bored as fuck until she can buy her own damn toys. I have no clue.

She doesn’t have a bath every night because she doesn’t need one every night. She doesn’t watch Nickelodeon because we don’t have cable – and I mean even the normal, basic, channel 3 to what? 28 cable. We have DVDs and VHSs and a library to borrow more from in one direction (which we go to every Wednesday, without fail) and a video store to rent from in the other (that’d be Friday’s venture – date night). We are entertained enough, commercial-free.

We don’t eat pork, either. We don’t go to church, but I’m not adverse to her deciding to check it out one day. I rarely have had a drink in front of her and she knows that beer and wine and vodka are drinks that adults shouldn’t share with children – she also once said that an eau de beer wearing dumpster diver in the liquor store was her daddy. Kids pick up on shit, you know?

I’m not trying to be anti-conformist, as a label. I’m not attempting to be radical, as one might have called me. Me? I’m putting my principles and morals and deal-breakers out for her to see. I’ve got a mind to attempt to raise her, as I think I would have liked to be.

And I wonder, as parents, isn’t that what a large chunk of us are doing? Trying to give our kids the opposites of what we had?

Related Posts with Thumbnails
  • I have to say that was beautifully written. This is the first time I have viewed your site and I am in love with it.

    Wonderful post.

    <abbr>Visit Average Girl to read...My Work Spouse.... As Promised</abbr>
  • like you owe any of us explanations?

    <abbr>Visit flutter to read...She</abbr>
  • The G File
    I like you. This is my first time on your blog, but won't be the last. Keep it up. I wish you all the success (in whatever shape of form you'd like this to be).
    I can understand why you'd like your kid to be home schooled. I don't have kids myself (only step kids), but from what I see, there's much that the public school system lacks. I was lucky to be educated in a private school that is one of the best in the area where I was raised, and yet, in spite of having an above-average intelligence, suffered from the way I was instructed because it didn't do enough to stimulate my ADHD brain.

    Now, having said that... I'm wondering if you'd be spreading yourself too thin by spending all that time with Isobel. I've read in another one of your posts that you are bipolar. So am I, which makes me wonder whether it's even more important for you to give some attention to what would contribute to your health. You're not the only mom out there who has too much of a good thing (meaning time alone in closed quarters with your daughter). Looking back at my childhood, my relationship with my own Mom would be much better now if she did take the time away from me that she needed. Less yelling, healthier for her...

    So I don't know... Is there a compromise? Maybe a school program that is part-time, so to speak?

    Hugs,

    G.
  • I think you are an awesome parent who has obviously put a lot of thought into how to raise this wonderful little kiddo of yours!

    <abbr>Visit Nicki to read...Life Going On...</abbr>
  • Al_Pal
    Very interesting.
    Vaccination is one of those big questions, isn't it?
    I have some hope that if I *do* eventually decide I want kids, that question will have had a lot more research & conclusions by that time. ;p
    I like that you spend your money on groceries, and a small apartment in an awesome neighborhood. :D
    There IS vegan chocolate out there. :D
    You can haz dairy free! :P
  • hey, do what you gotta do.

    I'd only add, that many of your blog posts are about the stress and challenges you feel providing for your child as it is. *maybe* school would be cool b/c it would give you time in the day to write and thus provide more income or just decompress? just say'n... not tell'n, ya dig?

    <abbr>Visit Jeremy to read...Madelyn the Radio Star</abbr>
  • When my daughter was little she would ask me to do some funky stuff to her hair, tie it up in little knots all over her head (looked like tiny bee hives), or put it in cornrows or a spiderweb pattern. I would do it because if she was confident enough to wear it, I wasn't going to take that away from her. Kids need choices, need to know they have some control over their own lives.

    I applaud you and how you are raising her daughter to be healthy, confident and self assured. Brava!

    <abbr>Visit Tara R. to read...Mac Daddy Smackdown</abbr>
  • All this does is define you as a good mother. Every choice that you make will turn her into who she is.

    I think you're doing pretty damn good.

    xo

    <abbr>Visit Miss to read...You made your bed</abbr>
  • my friend wrote a blog a couple weeks ago about vaccinations... it was an interesting read. something i'd never really thought about before.

    http://www.whattoexpect.com/blogs/himmeandbabymakes3/to-vaccinate-or-not-to-vaccinate-that-is-the-quest.aspx

    <abbr>Visit vancityrockgirl to read...one week today</abbr>
  • I'm with you on nearly everything except the Santa thing (cause Mama LOOOOOVES the commercialism of Clausmas) and the food. I have expectations of myself to have them eat better than they do, but I have a hard time living up to it.

    Kids NEED choices and I HATE the commercials they see from time to time when they happen to catch a Nick show rather than a Noggin show. The "I want that!" drives me nutso.

    I'm really nervous about Anna entering Kindergarten in the fall because she is so incredibly smart and shy. I wish there was an alternative close by, but right now there's not. I am slowly thinking of home school, but we'll give school a try first.

    <abbr>Visit Angie [A Whole Lot of Nothing] to read...Claire is Claire</abbr>
  • There's so much I agree with...except we do Santa and probably aren't as good with groceries as you are.

    <abbr>Visit Ashley to read...It’s officially official</abbr>
  • Uh the great Santa Claus debate! A constant battle in our house. I think it's a waste of time and money and goes against what the holidays are supposed to be about he says it's teaching kids a sense of imagination, magic and childhood joy... I say bullshit!
  • Girl, where I live, you're the parenting NORM. People look at me like I'm the freak because Gabriel's IS vaccinated. And, um, hello? I have my very own attachment-parented, breastfed, cloth-diapered, organic child who is NOT HIP ENOUGH. So people get all Judgy McJudgerson on you from both ends of the spectrum.

    Sounds like you're doing a great job.
  • It sounds to me like you're doing all the things I always said I'd do if I had kids. No lying about santa then revealing the truth later. No junk food. No TV.

    It sounds like you're a wonderful, caring, and thoughtful mother, and that's something you can't buy your kids. You and her, you'll do just fine. :)
  • Liza
    Ditto to all above...BUT being of the medical profession for many years and seeing no REAL evidence of otherwise...I disagree on the immunization part....stagger them if you will but don't eliminate them! Just my 2 sense....
  • I think every single mother should feel cofident in the choices they make for their child. I think our society has too much of the whole, parent like me syndrome. There are things I agree with you here, and some I don't. But, I think what matters is that we both parent our kids with love and with decisions that are our own.

    <abbr>Visit conversemomma to read...Butterfly Wings and Blogher</abbr>
  • Sounds like you are doing everything just right for her to me :-) You are empowering her to become a lovely, confident little girl who will one day blossom into a strong, self-assured woman. Well done!

    <abbr>Visit Shannon to read...Sick Baby, Round Three</abbr>
  • No. Not the opposite. Just better. Opposite happens when it was as bad as it was for you. But most of us - just want it to be better.

    <abbr>Visit lceel to read...The Kid - front to back</abbr>
  • Radical bad-ass.

    <abbr>Visit SingleParentDad to read...Flashbacks, Both Dreadful, And Wonderful</abbr>
  • I love so much of this and what you are doing. Teaching her the right foods, showing her your imperfections, showing her that the world is a meltingpot, and not buying her many toys.

    You know what?

    I bet she appreciates it SO much, when she becomes a mother, that she will give her kids much of the same that you did. I know that as a daughter, I do much the same that my mother did. You are all kinds of lovely.

    <abbr>Visit OHmommy to read...The. Best day ever.</abbr>
blog comments powered by Disqus